Language selection

Search

Are early and frequent fungicide applications on durum wheat beneficial in increasing grain productivity?

Set up an interview

Media Relations
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
1-866-345-7972
aafc.mediarelations-relationsmedias.aac@canada.ca

Fusarium head blight (FHB) and leaf spots are fungal diseases that can dramatically cut wheat yields and quality. For these reasons, there has been a heightened focus on spraying fungicides to mitigate associated crop losses. However, recent studies undertaken by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) will cause farmers to question early and frequent applications of fungicides for control of wheat diseases.

Timing and number of applications of fungicide

Between 2001 and 2006, AAFC researchers Myriam Fernandez and Bill May undertook two studies to examine how the timing and number of applications of the commonly recommended triazole fungicides affected durum wheat grown in southern Saskatchewan and Manitoba.

One of the studies, conducted in southeast Saskatchewan in 2004-2006 under relatively low disease pressure, showed that:

Grain downgrading might result from early and frequent fungicide application

In their 2001-2003 study, the researchers looked at the impact of single and double fungicide applications at flag leaf emergence and flowering stage. They saw a distinct trade off, as kernel discolourations (downgrading factors that can reduce profits) black point and red smudge were increased.

While fungicide applications showed a yield increase, the timing and number of applications was shown to have a negative effect on quality. For example, during the period of the study a single application of fungicide resulted in a 4.3% yield increase, and a second resulted in an 8.5% yield increase.  However, the researchers saw significant impacts on grain quality: application at either flag leaf elongation or flowering stage showed a 47% increase in black point compared to no fungicides being applied, and by 76% for double applications. Furthermore, red smudge increased by 17% for single fungicide applications, and by 57% for double applications, compared to no fungicides being applied.

As an example of the negative affect on quality, these increased rates of red smudge would have downgraded the crop from being No. 1 Canadian Western Amber Durum by 2015 rating standards, which reinforces that fungicides should only be applied when necessary and at the right time.

The observation of increased kernel discolouration as a result of fungicide application agrees with results observed in previous AAFC studies, such as by Wang et al., as well as those done at the Indian Head Agricultural Research Foundation (IHARF).

Fungicide application as a preventative measure questioned

None of the results support the recommendation that fungicides be applied to durum wheat crops on a 'preventative' basis, to increase grain yields. 

"Fungicides should be applied when disease pressure warrants it, and the potential for grain and quality losses exists. Faced with the recommendation of early fungicide applications as a preventative measure regardless of disease pressure, farmers need to consider that early and frequent fungicide applications to durum wheat might reduce grain quality and result in downgrading and potential profit loss."

- Bill May, Crop Management Agronomist, AAFC's Indian Head Research Farm

Fernandez also notes that the overuse of fungicides can result in the wheat pathogens developing increased resistance to the treatment.

More research on the relationship between kernel discolouration and fungicides needs to be conducted. In the meantime, farmers are encouraged to follow good crop management practices, such as growing wheat cultivars with resistance to the diseases prevalent in their region and rotating them with non-susceptible crop species. 

Key discoveries (benefits)

Photo gallery

Person's hand holds a single durum leaf speckled with tan spot.
Tan spot is one of many fungal diseases that affected durum plants. Photo courtesy Saskatchewan Ministry of Agriculture
Five wheat kernels with red smudge infection.
Wheat kernel affected by red smudge.
Plants heavily affected with leaf spot.
Plants heavily affected with leaf spot.

Related information

Report a problem on this page
Please select all that apply:
Date modified: