Evaluation of Problad Plus for the management of grey mold in greenhouse peppers
Project Code BPR14-050
Janice Elmhirst Elmhirst Diagnostics and Research, British Columbia, Canada
Diane Logeot Ag-Quest, Incorporated, Manitoba, Canada
To develop efficacy and crop tolerance data in support of a regulatory submission for the biopesticide Problad PlusTM for the management of grey mould (Botrytis cinerea) in greenhouse peppers
Summary of Results
Grey mould (Botrytis cinerea) is a serious problem in most places where greenhouse peppers are grown in Canada. During the annual Biopesticide Priority Setting Workshop in March 2013, Botrytis grey mould in greenhouse peppers was identified as a priority issue by Canadian growers, with Problad Plus™ selected as a potential solution for the management of this disease. Problad Plus™ is a broad spectrum, preventive biopesticide containing 20% of Banda de Lupinus albus doce (BLAD), a naturally occurring seed storage protein in sweet lupines. Problad Plus™ is registered by CEV, S.A. (Consumo em Verde, Portugal) in the United States under the trade name of Fracture™ on grapes, almonds, strawberries, tomatoes, and stone fruits for the control of diseases including Botrytis grey mould.
The Pesticide Risk Reduction Program is working with industry to facilitate the submission of an User Requested Minor Use Label Expansion (URMULE) to include this use in the Canadian registration of the product. The efficacy trials were conducted in British Colombia (B.C.) and Manitoba in 2014 to develop efficacy and tolerance data.
Problad Plus™ was evaluated in comparison to the commercial standards Fontelis (penthiopyrad) and Cease Biofungicide for the control of Botrytis grey mould in greenhouse pepper in B.C. and Manitoba under low to moderate disease pressures derived by inoculation. There were 4 treatments including untreated check (water only), Problad Plus™ at 1.86 litres per hectare (L/ha) and 3.72 L/ha, and Fontelis at 1.75 L/ha or Cease Biofungicide at 9.4 L/ha as the commercial standard. Each treatment had 4 replicates and was applied 6 times at an approximately weekly interval in the greenhouse. The diseased leaf incidence, diseased leaf severity, bloom grey mould, petiole lesions, stem cankers, and fruit rot were assessed for evaluation of efficacy.
During the trial in B.C., the higher rate of Problad Plus™ significantly reduced the mean percentage of diseased leaves by 40% and the mean number of botrytis leaf spots per plant by 64% compared to the untreated check. The lower rate of Problad Plus™ was not statistically different from the untreated check for the control of leaf disease on most treatment dates, but was more effective on petiole and stem lesions with 82% reduction in petiole lesions and 100% reduction in stem cankers. The performance of the lower rate was similar to effectiveness provided by the commercial standard Fontelis for the control of petiole lesions and stem cankers. The higher rate of Problad Plus™ was less effective on petiole and stem cankers and none of the treatments reduced botrytis grey mould on blooms, botrytis fruit rot, or botrytis ghost spot on fruit. There was no significant difference in marketable or total yield among all treatments.
During the trial in Manitoba, the two rates of Problad Plus™ did not provide significant efficacy compared with the untreated control, but numerically reduced disease severity by up to 30% and disease incidence of Botrytis grey mould by up to 50%. The performance of the two rates was similar to the commercial standard Cease Biofungicide.
No phytotoxicity was observed within either of the two trials.
The data from this project will be used to support a submission to Pest Management Regulatory Agency to add management of Botrytis grey mould in greenhouse peppers to the Canadian label for Problad Plus™.
- Date modified: